by Melissa Withers
Starting a company and leading one are two different jobs. Two jobs that the one person may not be equally good at. It’s painful when a founding CEO hits that wall, when the role of CEO no longer fits the skillset–or the disposition–of the very person whose insights were the raison d'etre for a company’s existence.
It happens all the time. Sometimes by attrition. Sometimes by the machinations of stakeholders who disagree about what’s best for a company. In every case, the job you take as a founding CEO is not the job you'll have in year three. I’ve seen the gaping delta between the two roles gobble up some talented people.
What makes us good at starting a company isn't always what makes us good at scaling it. Figuring that out in real time can be nails-down-a-chalkboard painful. For everyone.
It’s not just a mindset issue. Not just about talent. It’s a seismic shift in operating reality. The work of scaling is different from the work of starting. The things we celebrate in starters—scrappiness, blind speed, founder-led everything—builds one kind of operational muscle. Downstream, those same behaviors may yield diminished returns, turning you into a barrier to operational scale.
I call this stage of growth the ugly adolescence of entrepreneurship. If your company were a tween, your voice would be cracking. The shoes you took off last night at bedtime are too tight to slip back on in the morning. Nothing fits right. Same behaviors but different results.
It’s also when becoming a CEO doesn’t mean you can—or should—stay one.
The early signs that you're outgrowing your own playbook look an awful lot like normal startup chaos. Things grow at different speeds. Systems need to grow faster than you have skills to tackle. Head count may outrun culture building. Customers balk at once-good-enough fixes, but your bank account can’t float new infrastructure. By the time it's obvious, the pain is real.
Here’s the kicker: It's not just hard. It’s lonely in a way that's hard to explain. Everyone around you is talking about scaling the company. Very few people are talking about scaling the CEO. Changing how you operate can feel less like growth and more like losing yourself. You’re not stupid. You’re just inexperienced.
At this crossroads few founders voluntarily step aside but some do. Most white-knuckle it until they burn out or get fired. Some sink with the ship…with company failure being its own kind of pink slip. But SOME manage to grow into the role and when it works it is a beautiful thing to behold.
I have a founder in our portfolio who is well on her way to ‘making it’ all the way. I’ve been talking a bit recently about what she did to make it into this rarified rank.
She started the company from personal experience with a problem she wanted to solve. The product, from idea to real world distribution, was her brainchild. Fast forward, and she’s navigated fundraising, from early angel rounds to Series A. She’s built, scrapped, and rebuilt the market facing side of the business at least twice. She’s placed high risk bets on regulatory frameworks, walking the line between growth and the ever present threat of insolvency. She fired her cofounder and replaced many early employees, all while keeping an investor-heavy board calm and focused.
She’d be the first to tell you that the job she has isn’t the one she expected. Growth has been unpretty and heartbreaking, but also exhilarating and deeply satisfying. She made some pro-moves worth sharing:
Be the job. From early on she knew the boundaries of her responsibilities were ever-changing, but not ever-expanding. These changes didn’t mean liberation from unwanted tasks, it mostly meant letting go of things she actually liked doing, if only to make space for what needed to be done. Less time with the product. Less time with customers. More time overseeing, planning and communicating.
Pain over pretense. More than once she opened a conversation with three powerful words: Please help me. When asked hard questions, she wasn’t afraid to sometimes say, I don’t know. This transparency created trust across a close network of supporters. When things got a little rocky, no one panicked. It is never her against us. It is us against the world.
Learning isn’t always free. From early days she set the precedent that her development was a necessary company investment. When the company needed a version of her that didn't exist yet, she went and built it. She hired an executive coach early on, and then another, when it was time for a more sophisticated resource. Treat your development as a CEO like any other line item that drives revenue. Because it does.
The founders I admire most aren't the ones who never struggled through the awkward years. They're the ones who knew the company deserved a CEO who could keep up with it, did the work to become that person, or stepped aside when they weren’t the right fit.
Our founder isn’t done. The job will change on her again, probably sooner than she’d like. But she’s built the one thing that makes the next version of the job survivable: a habit of asking for help before she needs it. Godspeed.
———
More About the Author
RevUp Capital Managing Partner Melissa Withers is a bullish advocate for innovating the ways in which new companies are funded and supported. Beyond building new economic models for early stage investing, Melissa is also committed to directing more entrepreneurial funding to those underserved and overlooked by traditional VC.
More About RevUp Capital
RevUp Capital invests in B2B and B2C companies that are revenue-driven and ready to double down on growth. We deploy cash and capacity to help companies grow from $1-3M to $10-30M, quickly and efficiently, using a revenue-based model. Companies enter our portfolio with $500K-$3M in revenue, a strong growth rate, and a team that’s ready to scale. Our typical investment range is $300K-$500K.
Learn More at www.revupfund.com
How We Invest
We built RevUp to invest into B2B and B2C companies ascending the $1M-$10M growth curve. We know from experience—and from the stellar performance of our portfolio—that this curve can be conquered. But, having the right resources and support along the way is critical to success.
RevUp combines non-dilutive investment with hands-on support to help companies build stronger, more scalable infrastructure for growth. And, we do it using a non-dilutive model. Our goal? Give companies the best shot at success while preserving founder equity, optionality, and autonomy.
For more info visit here.